{ "tool_id": "art-712-workforce-board-roi", "note": "Thirty-two vectors. Vector 32 (BND-WIOA-TARGETS-CALLER) supplies caller wioa_targets (negotiated per 20 CFR 677.190) over the same inputs as vector 1, flipping the scorecard from meets to exceeds; vector 1 without them keeps the Apex illustrative defaults (targets_source apex_defaults). Vector 1 is the manifest example (adult/manufacturing, Below Target with zero tax recapture, ART712_BELOW_TARGET + ART712_NO_TAX_RECAPTURE). apex-A_excellent..apex-G_default_exited carry the seven Apex #15 live-result vectors (APEXPORT-WF15 VECTORS.md section A): the ported kernel reproduces the Apex tool benchmark statuses, cost metrics and indicator counts EXACTLY on all seven; only the wage/ROI block differs, and only where the sector baseline was corrected to the official BLS QCEW Q3 2023 figure (DIFFERS.md) — the single grade flip is B_strong (dislocated_worker/healthcare), Strong under the Apex baseline 57800 (return 1.953) and Below Target under the official 62452 (return 0.488). BND-* carry the 23 boundary fixtures (VECTORS.md section B), one input pair at and just past the boundary for every comparator (pct exceeds at target+2pp, pct meets at target-1pp, earnings exceeds at target*1.05, earnings meets at target, null->na, employedQ2/credentialed zero-vs-one, earnings-gain zero-vs-positive, tax-recapture null, the three grade thresholds, breakeven display cutoff). All output_payload values are the committed kernel compute() outputs; golden_hash is executionHash(policy_parameters, output_payload) per _hash.mjs (OCG §6 JCS-SHA-256). Apex page fetched 2026-10-05, sha256 a83d547ae9788bfaabac0be084b566551f00252fe92186c45a5c929ac8c400f9. human_sign_off: PENDING.", "vectors": [ { "name": "manifest-example-adult-manufacturing", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Advanced Manufacturing Cohort 3", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "manufacturing", "total_budget": 500000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 150, "participants_exited": 120, "emp_rate_q2": 76, "emp_rate_q4": 74, "median_earnings_q2": 6200, "credential_rate": 53, "skill_gains_rate": 56 }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Advanced Manufacturing Cohort 3", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "manufacturing", "sector_label": "Manufacturing", "total_budget": 500000, "participants_enrolled": 150, "participants_exited": 120, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 3333.3333333333335, "employed_q2": 91, "credentialed": 64, "cost_per_employed_q2": 5494.505494505494, "cost_per_credential": 7812.5, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 76, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "meets" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 74, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "meets" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": 6200, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "meets" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": 53, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "meets" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": 56, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "meets" } ], "indicators_scored": 5, "indicators_met": 5, "indicators_exceeded": 0, "annualized_earnings": 24800, "sector_baseline_annual": 77844, "earnings_gain_annual": -53044, "annual_tax_recapture": 0, "breakeven_months": null, "three_year_net_benefit": -500000, "return_per_dollar_3yr": 0, "grade": "Below Target", "grade_sub": "Program may benefit from a strategic review", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "9bee03e7cb121f0c2fbcb71add3552a3ba06919bf5a8259aaf56aa1c9207fa9f" }, { "name": "apex-A_excellent", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Hospitality Adult Strong", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "hospitality", "total_budget": 300000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 150, "participants_exited": 120, "emp_rate_q2": 80, "emp_rate_q4": 80, "median_earnings_q2": 20000, "credential_rate": 60, "skill_gains_rate": 60 }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Hospitality Adult Strong", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "hospitality", "sector_label": "Accommodation & Food Services", "total_budget": 300000, "participants_enrolled": 150, "participants_exited": 120, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 2000, "employed_q2": 96, "credentialed": 72, "cost_per_employed_q2": 3125, "cost_per_credential": 4166.666666666667, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 80, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 80, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": 20000, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": 60, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": 60, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" } ], "indicators_scored": 5, "indicators_met": 5, "indicators_exceeded": 5, "annualized_earnings": 80000, "sector_baseline_annual": 28600, "earnings_gain_annual": 51400, "annual_tax_recapture": 1480320, "breakeven_months": 2.431906614785992, "three_year_net_benefit": 4140960, "return_per_dollar_3yr": 14.8032, "grade": "Excellent", "grade_sub": "Strong taxpayer return with benchmark-exceeding outcomes", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "fe213a7158d73a5a2af9a2ca26a7fd74bf8865434cdb7f6b9f04445a3df910da" }, { "name": "apex-B_strong", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Healthcare DW", "program_type": "dislocated_worker", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "healthcare", "total_budget": 200000, "avg_training_weeks": 20, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 90, "emp_rate_q2": 78, "emp_rate_q4": 75, "median_earnings_q2": 16000, "credential_rate": 62, "skill_gains_rate": 55 }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Healthcare DW", "program_type": "dislocated_worker", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "healthcare", "sector_label": "Healthcare & Social Assistance", "total_budget": 200000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 90, "avg_training_weeks": 20, "cost_per_participant": 2000, "employed_q2": 70, "credentialed": 56, "cost_per_employed_q2": 2857.1428571428573, "cost_per_credential": 3571.4285714285716, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 78, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 75, "target": 73, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": 16000, "target": 8100, "isEarnings": true, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": 62, "target": 60, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": 55, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" } ], "indicators_scored": 5, "indicators_met": 5, "indicators_exceeded": 5, "annualized_earnings": 64000, "sector_baseline_annual": 62452, "earnings_gain_annual": 1548, "annual_tax_recapture": 32508, "breakeven_months": 73.82798080472499, "three_year_net_benefit": -102476, "return_per_dollar_3yr": 0.48762, "grade": "Below Target", "grade_sub": "Program may benefit from a strategic review", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "03923c649789a45339a00b7a4c2f507bf96d272763bc699e4b021b356adb2546" }, { "name": "apex-C_below", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Youth Retail Mixed", "program_type": "youth", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "retail", "total_budget": 150000, "avg_training_weeks": 10, "participants_enrolled": 120, "participants_exited": 100, "emp_rate_q2": 68, "emp_rate_q4": 72, "median_earnings_q2": 4000, "credential_rate": 65, "skill_gains_rate": 60 }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Youth Retail Mixed", "program_type": "youth", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "retail", "sector_label": "Retail Trade", "total_budget": 150000, "participants_enrolled": 120, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": 10, "cost_per_participant": 1250, "employed_q2": 68, "credentialed": 65, "cost_per_employed_q2": 2205.8823529411766, "cost_per_credential": 2307.6923076923076, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment/Education/Training Rate – Q2 (%)", "userVal": 68, "target": 67, "isEarnings": false, "status": "meets" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment/Education/Training Rate – Q4 (%)", "userVal": 72, "target": 72, "isEarnings": false, "status": "meets" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": 4000, "target": 3400, "isEarnings": true, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": 65, "target": 68, "isEarnings": false, "status": "below" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": 60, "target": 58, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" } ], "indicators_scored": 5, "indicators_met": 4, "indicators_exceeded": 2, "annualized_earnings": 16000, "sector_baseline_annual": 40716, "earnings_gain_annual": -24716, "annual_tax_recapture": 0, "breakeven_months": null, "three_year_net_benefit": -150000, "return_per_dollar_3yr": 0, "grade": "Below Target", "grade_sub": "Program may benefit from a strategic review", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "d7b6740a6f84e37d5e7d3adba188f1070973b950201df6ea79d0834afc80b4c4" }, { "name": "apex-D_moderate", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Hospitality Adult Moderate", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "hospitality", "total_budget": 2000000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 80, "emp_rate_q2": 76, "emp_rate_q4": 74, "median_earnings_q2": 20000, "credential_rate": 50, "skill_gains_rate": 50 }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Hospitality Adult Moderate", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "hospitality", "sector_label": "Accommodation & Food Services", "total_budget": 2000000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 80, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 20000, "employed_q2": 61, "credentialed": 40, "cost_per_employed_q2": 32786.88524590164, "cost_per_credential": 50000, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 76, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "meets" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 74, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "meets" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": 20000, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": 50, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "below" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": 50, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "below" } ], "indicators_scored": 5, "indicators_met": 3, "indicators_exceeded": 1, "annualized_earnings": 80000, "sector_baseline_annual": 28600, "earnings_gain_annual": 51400, "annual_tax_recapture": 940620, "breakeven_months": 25.515085794475983, "three_year_net_benefit": 821860, "return_per_dollar_3yr": 1.41093, "grade": "Moderate", "grade_sub": "Positive return; selected benchmarks need improvement", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "bf9dcf8998f548711983a3de20460677aefb031c3325dc6cd9641447dc829389" }, { "name": "apex-E_scored", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Scored No Q2 Employment", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "construction", "total_budget": 400000, "avg_training_weeks": null, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 80, "emp_rate_q2": null, "emp_rate_q4": 75, "median_earnings_q2": 9000, "credential_rate": 54, "skill_gains_rate": 57 }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Scored No Q2 Employment", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "construction", "sector_label": "Construction", "total_budget": 400000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 80, "avg_training_weeks": null, "cost_per_participant": 4000, "employed_q2": null, "credentialed": 43, "cost_per_employed_q2": null, "cost_per_credential": 9302.32558139535, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 75, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "meets" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": 9000, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": 54, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "meets" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": 57, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "meets" } ], "indicators_scored": 4, "indicators_met": 4, "indicators_exceeded": 1, "annualized_earnings": 36000, "sector_baseline_annual": 75036, "earnings_gain_annual": -39036, "annual_tax_recapture": null, "breakeven_months": null, "three_year_net_benefit": null, "return_per_dollar_3yr": null, "grade": "Scored", "grade_sub": "Enter median earnings to unlock full ROI grade", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "9c4ceb271d02ebcd442ea2a1f9a6f0eedb84c94c1207bf6966e1eabf74348d99" }, { "name": "apex-F_pending", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Pending Program", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "manufacturing", "total_budget": 500000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 150, "participants_exited": 120, "emp_rate_q2": null, "emp_rate_q4": null, "median_earnings_q2": null, "credential_rate": null, "skill_gains_rate": null }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Pending Program", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "manufacturing", "sector_label": "Manufacturing", "total_budget": 500000, "participants_enrolled": 150, "participants_exited": 120, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 3333.3333333333335, "employed_q2": null, "credentialed": null, "cost_per_employed_q2": null, "cost_per_credential": null, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": null, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "na" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" } ], "indicators_scored": 0, "indicators_met": 0, "indicators_exceeded": 0, "annualized_earnings": null, "sector_baseline_annual": 77844, "earnings_gain_annual": null, "annual_tax_recapture": null, "breakeven_months": null, "three_year_net_benefit": null, "return_per_dollar_3yr": null, "grade": "Pending Data", "grade_sub": "Enter outcome metrics to generate benchmark comparison", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "415605e3d7234a23308800104a2670fa0fda63e41ee7b7e0da44fad63edf9933" }, { "name": "apex-G_default_exited", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Construction Default Exited", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2022", "sector": "construction", "total_budget": 400000, "avg_training_weeks": null, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": null, "emp_rate_q2": 77, "emp_rate_q4": 75, "median_earnings_q2": 9000, "credential_rate": 54, "skill_gains_rate": 57 }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Construction Default Exited", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2022", "sector": "construction", "sector_label": "Construction", "total_budget": 400000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": null, "cost_per_participant": 4000, "employed_q2": 77, "credentialed": 54, "cost_per_employed_q2": 5194.805194805195, "cost_per_credential": 7407.407407407408, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 77, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "meets" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 75, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "meets" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": 9000, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": 54, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "meets" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": 57, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "meets" } ], "indicators_scored": 5, "indicators_met": 5, "indicators_exceeded": 1, "annualized_earnings": 36000, "sector_baseline_annual": 75036, "earnings_gain_annual": -39036, "annual_tax_recapture": 0, "breakeven_months": null, "three_year_net_benefit": -400000, "return_per_dollar_3yr": 0, "grade": "Below Target", "grade_sub": "Program may benefit from a strategic review", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "b6259d68e47a9f520b824f9f96589f9400bffc8351b0468c4d793c3fed0a02f2" }, { "name": "BND-PCT-EXCEEDS-AT", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "total_budget": 1000000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "emp_rate_q2": 78, "emp_rate_q4": null, "median_earnings_q2": null, "credential_rate": null, "skill_gains_rate": null }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "sector_label": "Other / Mixed Sectors", "total_budget": 1000000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 10000, "employed_q2": 78, "credentialed": null, "cost_per_employed_q2": 12820.51282051282, "cost_per_credential": null, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 78, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": null, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "na" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" } ], "indicators_scored": 1, "indicators_met": 1, "indicators_exceeded": 1, "annualized_earnings": null, "sector_baseline_annual": 69056, "earnings_gain_annual": null, "annual_tax_recapture": 0, "breakeven_months": null, "three_year_net_benefit": -1000000, "return_per_dollar_3yr": 0, "grade": "Below Target", "grade_sub": "Program may benefit from a strategic review", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "53f5a75fc10c7be546ce0d5bc5bbfacda7aaad00a8b39cdb5ec246fa655585cb" }, { "name": "BND-PCT-EXCEEDS-PAST", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "total_budget": 1000000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "emp_rate_q2": 77.9, "emp_rate_q4": null, "median_earnings_q2": null, "credential_rate": null, "skill_gains_rate": null }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "sector_label": "Other / Mixed Sectors", "total_budget": 1000000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 10000, "employed_q2": 78, "credentialed": null, "cost_per_employed_q2": 12820.51282051282, "cost_per_credential": null, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 77.9, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "meets" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": null, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "na" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" } ], "indicators_scored": 1, "indicators_met": 1, "indicators_exceeded": 0, "annualized_earnings": null, "sector_baseline_annual": 69056, "earnings_gain_annual": null, "annual_tax_recapture": 0, "breakeven_months": null, "three_year_net_benefit": -1000000, "return_per_dollar_3yr": 0, "grade": "Below Target", "grade_sub": "Program may benefit from a strategic review", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "e8115fa1c1f77c5d432d85c0ef71369024333a36f125d0700aae765311908b4b" }, { "name": "BND-PCT-MEETS-AT", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "total_budget": 1000000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "emp_rate_q2": 75, "emp_rate_q4": null, "median_earnings_q2": null, "credential_rate": null, "skill_gains_rate": null }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "sector_label": "Other / Mixed Sectors", "total_budget": 1000000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 10000, "employed_q2": 75, "credentialed": null, "cost_per_employed_q2": 13333.333333333334, "cost_per_credential": null, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 75, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "meets" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": null, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "na" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" } ], "indicators_scored": 1, "indicators_met": 1, "indicators_exceeded": 0, "annualized_earnings": null, "sector_baseline_annual": 69056, "earnings_gain_annual": null, "annual_tax_recapture": 0, "breakeven_months": null, "three_year_net_benefit": -1000000, "return_per_dollar_3yr": 0, "grade": "Below Target", "grade_sub": "Program may benefit from a strategic review", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "6248eaef259827e38b9bc252569516eb94917f802bbae9ba8608ccc34be66902" }, { "name": "BND-PCT-MEETS-PAST", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "total_budget": 1000000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "emp_rate_q2": 74.9, "emp_rate_q4": null, "median_earnings_q2": null, "credential_rate": null, "skill_gains_rate": null }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "sector_label": "Other / Mixed Sectors", "total_budget": 1000000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 10000, "employed_q2": 75, "credentialed": null, "cost_per_employed_q2": 13333.333333333334, "cost_per_credential": null, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 74.9, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "below" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": null, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "na" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" } ], "indicators_scored": 1, "indicators_met": 0, "indicators_exceeded": 0, "annualized_earnings": null, "sector_baseline_annual": 69056, "earnings_gain_annual": null, "annual_tax_recapture": 0, "breakeven_months": null, "three_year_net_benefit": -1000000, "return_per_dollar_3yr": 0, "grade": "Below Target", "grade_sub": "Program may benefit from a strategic review", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "be705d72615c09181393697ab5f0001480f501e69f22f4a77ecf1056bcb98c06" }, { "name": "BND-EARN-EXCEEDS-AT", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "total_budget": 1000000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "emp_rate_q2": null, "emp_rate_q4": null, "median_earnings_q2": 6510, "credential_rate": null, "skill_gains_rate": null }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "sector_label": "Other / Mixed Sectors", "total_budget": 1000000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 10000, "employed_q2": null, "credentialed": null, "cost_per_employed_q2": null, "cost_per_credential": null, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": 6510, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" } ], "indicators_scored": 1, "indicators_met": 1, "indicators_exceeded": 1, "annualized_earnings": 26040, "sector_baseline_annual": 69056, "earnings_gain_annual": -43016, "annual_tax_recapture": null, "breakeven_months": null, "three_year_net_benefit": null, "return_per_dollar_3yr": null, "grade": "Scored", "grade_sub": "Enter median earnings to unlock full ROI grade", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "5fe98d8df5d3c31b041d084d732e9eeecc969cc5276223b202ffa90fa5d83ee4" }, { "name": "BND-EARN-EXCEEDS-PAST", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "total_budget": 1000000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "emp_rate_q2": null, "emp_rate_q4": null, "median_earnings_q2": 6509.9, "credential_rate": null, "skill_gains_rate": null }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "sector_label": "Other / Mixed Sectors", "total_budget": 1000000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 10000, "employed_q2": null, "credentialed": null, "cost_per_employed_q2": null, "cost_per_credential": null, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": 6509.9, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "meets" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" } ], "indicators_scored": 1, "indicators_met": 1, "indicators_exceeded": 0, "annualized_earnings": 26039.6, "sector_baseline_annual": 69056, "earnings_gain_annual": -43016.4, "annual_tax_recapture": null, "breakeven_months": null, "three_year_net_benefit": null, "return_per_dollar_3yr": null, "grade": "Scored", "grade_sub": "Enter median earnings to unlock full ROI grade", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "457f63d70a2ccc1c28be9741d22d627ede770fbc1d20f837700564c0e5768c17" }, { "name": "BND-EARN-MEETS-AT", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "total_budget": 1000000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "emp_rate_q2": null, "emp_rate_q4": null, "median_earnings_q2": 6200, "credential_rate": null, "skill_gains_rate": null }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "sector_label": "Other / Mixed Sectors", "total_budget": 1000000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 10000, "employed_q2": null, "credentialed": null, "cost_per_employed_q2": null, "cost_per_credential": null, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": 6200, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "meets" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" } ], "indicators_scored": 1, "indicators_met": 1, "indicators_exceeded": 0, "annualized_earnings": 24800, "sector_baseline_annual": 69056, "earnings_gain_annual": -44256, "annual_tax_recapture": null, "breakeven_months": null, "three_year_net_benefit": null, "return_per_dollar_3yr": null, "grade": "Scored", "grade_sub": "Enter median earnings to unlock full ROI grade", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "0ddfe7989f061760dd1ce971e5680d60c65b977ebc14cdfddf044b8ec6a77399" }, { "name": "BND-EARN-MEETS-PAST", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "total_budget": 1000000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "emp_rate_q2": null, "emp_rate_q4": null, "median_earnings_q2": 6199.9, "credential_rate": null, "skill_gains_rate": null }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "sector_label": "Other / Mixed Sectors", "total_budget": 1000000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 10000, "employed_q2": null, "credentialed": null, "cost_per_employed_q2": null, "cost_per_credential": null, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": 6199.9, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "below" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" } ], "indicators_scored": 1, "indicators_met": 0, "indicators_exceeded": 0, "annualized_earnings": 24799.6, "sector_baseline_annual": 69056, "earnings_gain_annual": -44256.4, "annual_tax_recapture": null, "breakeven_months": null, "three_year_net_benefit": null, "return_per_dollar_3yr": null, "grade": "Scored", "grade_sub": "Enter median earnings to unlock full ROI grade", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "9293f4d39b14199b7702ffc4b2300b67522e4a177bea4c5202782d392e27e2e2" }, { "name": "BND-NULL-NA", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "total_budget": 1000000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "emp_rate_q2": null, "emp_rate_q4": null, "median_earnings_q2": null, "credential_rate": null, "skill_gains_rate": null }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "sector_label": "Other / Mixed Sectors", "total_budget": 1000000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 10000, "employed_q2": null, "credentialed": null, "cost_per_employed_q2": null, "cost_per_credential": null, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": null, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "na" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" } ], "indicators_scored": 0, "indicators_met": 0, "indicators_exceeded": 0, "annualized_earnings": null, "sector_baseline_annual": 69056, "earnings_gain_annual": null, "annual_tax_recapture": null, "breakeven_months": null, "three_year_net_benefit": null, "return_per_dollar_3yr": null, "grade": "Pending Data", "grade_sub": "Enter outcome metrics to generate benchmark comparison", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "b0c7f793f983cffe0c4166be4c80582d3335d80117980c49c73db4ffad9c5073" }, { "name": "BND-EMPQ2-ZERO", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "total_budget": 1000000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "emp_rate_q2": 0, "emp_rate_q4": null, "median_earnings_q2": null, "credential_rate": null, "skill_gains_rate": null }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "sector_label": "Other / Mixed Sectors", "total_budget": 1000000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 10000, "employed_q2": 0, "credentialed": null, "cost_per_employed_q2": null, "cost_per_credential": null, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 0, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "below" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": null, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "na" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" } ], "indicators_scored": 1, "indicators_met": 0, "indicators_exceeded": 0, "annualized_earnings": null, "sector_baseline_annual": 69056, "earnings_gain_annual": null, "annual_tax_recapture": 0, "breakeven_months": null, "three_year_net_benefit": -1000000, "return_per_dollar_3yr": 0, "grade": "Below Target", "grade_sub": "Program may benefit from a strategic review", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "7b6b0c82f5042ce9fdeccd913d50174a26350edfd69f77aa969e2da07268a81c" }, { "name": "BND-EMPQ2-ONE", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "total_budget": 1000000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "emp_rate_q2": 1, "emp_rate_q4": null, "median_earnings_q2": null, "credential_rate": null, "skill_gains_rate": null }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "sector_label": "Other / Mixed Sectors", "total_budget": 1000000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 10000, "employed_q2": 1, "credentialed": null, "cost_per_employed_q2": 1000000, "cost_per_credential": null, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 1, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "below" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": null, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "na" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" } ], "indicators_scored": 1, "indicators_met": 0, "indicators_exceeded": 0, "annualized_earnings": null, "sector_baseline_annual": 69056, "earnings_gain_annual": null, "annual_tax_recapture": 0, "breakeven_months": null, "three_year_net_benefit": -1000000, "return_per_dollar_3yr": 0, "grade": "Below Target", "grade_sub": "Program may benefit from a strategic review", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "6aceccef1fe1f15e5c4007186c9a6879494d114af03f547ad841ce157f64b230" }, { "name": "BND-CRED-ZERO", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "total_budget": 1000000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "emp_rate_q2": null, "emp_rate_q4": null, "median_earnings_q2": null, "credential_rate": 0, "skill_gains_rate": null }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "sector_label": "Other / Mixed Sectors", "total_budget": 1000000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 10000, "employed_q2": null, "credentialed": 0, "cost_per_employed_q2": null, "cost_per_credential": null, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": null, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "na" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": 0, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "below" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" } ], "indicators_scored": 1, "indicators_met": 0, "indicators_exceeded": 0, "annualized_earnings": null, "sector_baseline_annual": 69056, "earnings_gain_annual": null, "annual_tax_recapture": null, "breakeven_months": null, "three_year_net_benefit": null, "return_per_dollar_3yr": null, "grade": "Scored", "grade_sub": "Enter median earnings to unlock full ROI grade", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "dd65ba6761a3cad93ec98a2aac550313ce7b2db75624ca6cd8b6d5e4b8aeced1" }, { "name": "BND-CRED-ONE", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "total_budget": 1000000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "emp_rate_q2": null, "emp_rate_q4": null, "median_earnings_q2": null, "credential_rate": 1, "skill_gains_rate": null }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "sector_label": "Other / Mixed Sectors", "total_budget": 1000000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 10000, "employed_q2": null, "credentialed": 1, "cost_per_employed_q2": null, "cost_per_credential": 1000000, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": null, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "na" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": 1, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "below" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" } ], "indicators_scored": 1, "indicators_met": 0, "indicators_exceeded": 0, "annualized_earnings": null, "sector_baseline_annual": 69056, "earnings_gain_annual": null, "annual_tax_recapture": null, "breakeven_months": null, "three_year_net_benefit": null, "return_per_dollar_3yr": null, "grade": "Scored", "grade_sub": "Enter median earnings to unlock full ROI grade", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "ea60398b045f7ae6449a08503edaebd1f686d7c916f6c11cd2d076ebb6f804d5" }, { "name": "BND-GAIN-ZERO", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "total_budget": 1000000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "emp_rate_q2": 76, "emp_rate_q4": null, "median_earnings_q2": 17264, "credential_rate": null, "skill_gains_rate": null }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "sector_label": "Other / Mixed Sectors", "total_budget": 1000000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 10000, "employed_q2": 76, "credentialed": null, "cost_per_employed_q2": 13157.894736842105, "cost_per_credential": null, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 76, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "meets" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": 17264, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" } ], "indicators_scored": 2, "indicators_met": 2, "indicators_exceeded": 1, "annualized_earnings": 69056, "sector_baseline_annual": 69056, "earnings_gain_annual": 0, "annual_tax_recapture": 0, "breakeven_months": null, "three_year_net_benefit": -1000000, "return_per_dollar_3yr": 0, "grade": "Below Target", "grade_sub": "Program may benefit from a strategic review", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "3a53b53087bed28f3c8c0fda0cfb9031e3cda4f9a593d8205893754068e46ad6" }, { "name": "BND-GAIN-PAST", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "total_budget": 1000000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "emp_rate_q2": 76, "emp_rate_q4": null, "median_earnings_q2": 17264.1, "credential_rate": null, "skill_gains_rate": null }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "sector_label": "Other / Mixed Sectors", "total_budget": 1000000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 10000, "employed_q2": 76, "credentialed": null, "cost_per_employed_q2": 13157.894736842105, "cost_per_credential": null, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 76, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "meets" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": 17264.1, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" } ], "indicators_scored": 2, "indicators_met": 2, "indicators_exceeded": 1, "annualized_earnings": 69056.4, "sector_baseline_annual": 69056, "earnings_gain_annual": 0.39999999999417923, "annual_tax_recapture": 9.119999999867286, "breakeven_months": 1315789.4737033579, "three_year_net_benefit": -999972.6400000004, "return_per_dollar_3yr": 0.000027359999999601856, "grade": "Below Target", "grade_sub": "Program may benefit from a strategic review", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "0cdbf4cada99b759de87c8afd27982d06955de0dcc3c5e0c42ce7a9a28847063" }, { "name": "BND-TAXRECAP-NULL", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "total_budget": 1000000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "emp_rate_q2": null, "emp_rate_q4": null, "median_earnings_q2": 9000, "credential_rate": 54, "skill_gains_rate": 57 }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "sector_label": "Other / Mixed Sectors", "total_budget": 1000000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 10000, "employed_q2": null, "credentialed": 54, "cost_per_employed_q2": null, "cost_per_credential": 18518.51851851852, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": 9000, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": 54, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "meets" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": 57, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "meets" } ], "indicators_scored": 3, "indicators_met": 3, "indicators_exceeded": 1, "annualized_earnings": 36000, "sector_baseline_annual": 69056, "earnings_gain_annual": -33056, "annual_tax_recapture": null, "breakeven_months": null, "three_year_net_benefit": null, "return_per_dollar_3yr": null, "grade": "Scored", "grade_sub": "Enter median earnings to unlock full ROI grade", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "a887c4653b6733027882c4bfd11f5f73e8fe227a4468a90b978988ab2559b034" }, { "name": "BND-GRADE-EXCELLENT-AT", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "total_budget": 1000000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "emp_rate_q2": 78, "emp_rate_q4": 76, "median_earnings_q2": 24386.507122507122, "credential_rate": 55, "skill_gains_rate": 50 }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "sector_label": "Other / Mixed Sectors", "total_budget": 1000000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 10000, "employed_q2": 78, "credentialed": 55, "cost_per_employed_q2": 12820.51282051282, "cost_per_credential": 18181.81818181818, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 78, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 76, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": 24386.507122507122, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": 55, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": 50, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "below" } ], "indicators_scored": 5, "indicators_met": 4, "indicators_exceeded": 4, "annualized_earnings": 97546.02849002849, "sector_baseline_annual": 69056, "earnings_gain_annual": 28490.02849002849, "annual_tax_recapture": 666666.6666666666, "breakeven_months": 18, "three_year_net_benefit": 1000000, "return_per_dollar_3yr": 2, "grade": "Excellent", "grade_sub": "Strong taxpayer return with benchmark-exceeding outcomes", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "ff87a26e79e26650d3b001bc449068dba4efb4b9564674ab74f0f3840f355701" }, { "name": "BND-GRADE-EXCELLENT-PAST", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "total_budget": 1000000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "emp_rate_q2": 78, "emp_rate_q4": 76, "median_earnings_q2": 24382.94586894587, "credential_rate": 55, "skill_gains_rate": 50 }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "sector_label": "Other / Mixed Sectors", "total_budget": 1000000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 10000, "employed_q2": 78, "credentialed": 55, "cost_per_employed_q2": 12820.51282051282, "cost_per_credential": 18181.81818181818, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 78, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 76, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": 24382.94586894587, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": 55, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": 50, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "below" } ], "indicators_scored": 5, "indicators_met": 4, "indicators_exceeded": 4, "annualized_earnings": 97531.78347578348, "sector_baseline_annual": 69056, "earnings_gain_annual": 28475.78347578348, "annual_tax_recapture": 666333.3333333334, "breakeven_months": 18.009004502251123, "three_year_net_benefit": 999000, "return_per_dollar_3yr": 1.999, "grade": "Strong", "grade_sub": "Above-average return with solid WIOA benchmark performance", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "7921d8310dcc0eaf21046a588f3437e46b0b45c500f34c3889dca978874615fc" }, { "name": "BND-GRADE-STRONG-AT", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "total_budget": 1000000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "emp_rate_q2": 78, "emp_rate_q4": 76, "median_earnings_q2": 22605.880341880344, "credential_rate": 50, "skill_gains_rate": 50 }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "sector_label": "Other / Mixed Sectors", "total_budget": 1000000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 10000, "employed_q2": 78, "credentialed": 50, "cost_per_employed_q2": 12820.51282051282, "cost_per_credential": 20000, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 78, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 76, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": 22605.880341880344, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": 50, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "below" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": 50, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "below" } ], "indicators_scored": 5, "indicators_met": 3, "indicators_exceeded": 3, "annualized_earnings": 90423.52136752137, "sector_baseline_annual": 69056, "earnings_gain_annual": 21367.521367521374, "annual_tax_recapture": 500000.0000000001, "breakeven_months": 23.999999999999993, "three_year_net_benefit": 500000.00000000047, "return_per_dollar_3yr": 1.5000000000000004, "grade": "Strong", "grade_sub": "Above-average return with solid WIOA benchmark performance", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "2e197a9ed48bd61a6eef6aba3ad592132fd898d4e4075eebdd2b22ce2f47e5ad" }, { "name": "BND-GRADE-STRONG-PAST", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "total_budget": 1000000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "emp_rate_q2": 78, "emp_rate_q4": 76, "median_earnings_q2": 22602.319088319087, "credential_rate": 50, "skill_gains_rate": 50 }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "sector_label": "Other / Mixed Sectors", "total_budget": 1000000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 10000, "employed_q2": 78, "credentialed": 50, "cost_per_employed_q2": 12820.51282051282, "cost_per_credential": 20000, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 78, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 76, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": 22602.319088319087, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": 50, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "below" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": 50, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "below" } ], "indicators_scored": 5, "indicators_met": 3, "indicators_exceeded": 3, "annualized_earnings": 90409.27635327635, "sector_baseline_annual": 69056, "earnings_gain_annual": 21353.27635327635, "annual_tax_recapture": 499666.66666666657, "breakeven_months": 24.016010673782525, "three_year_net_benefit": 498999.99999999977, "return_per_dollar_3yr": 1.4989999999999997, "grade": "Moderate", "grade_sub": "Positive return; selected benchmarks need improvement", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "2cbfd25eb4072deec0a9ee35c91c9118d64b9e436ef56da11e1b74107c228259" }, { "name": "BND-GRADE-MODERATE-AT", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "total_budget": 1000000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "emp_rate_q2": 78, "emp_rate_q4": 50, "median_earnings_q2": 20825.25356125356, "credential_rate": 50, "skill_gains_rate": 50 }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "sector_label": "Other / Mixed Sectors", "total_budget": 1000000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 10000, "employed_q2": 78, "credentialed": 50, "cost_per_employed_q2": 12820.51282051282, "cost_per_credential": 20000, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 78, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 50, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "below" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": 20825.25356125356, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": 50, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "below" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": 50, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "below" } ], "indicators_scored": 5, "indicators_met": 2, "indicators_exceeded": 2, "annualized_earnings": 83301.01424501424, "sector_baseline_annual": 69056, "earnings_gain_annual": 14245.014245014245, "annual_tax_recapture": 333333.3333333333, "breakeven_months": 36, "three_year_net_benefit": 0, "return_per_dollar_3yr": 1, "grade": "Moderate", "grade_sub": "Positive return; selected benchmarks need improvement", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "c9b13d98370b5ca65625c8cd1c32bcc4811a77f747e15bd7ddf0b872dbdc7b95" }, { "name": "BND-GRADE-MODERATE-PAST", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "total_budget": 1000000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "emp_rate_q2": 78, "emp_rate_q4": 50, "median_earnings_q2": 20821.69230769231, "credential_rate": 50, "skill_gains_rate": 50 }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "sector_label": "Other / Mixed Sectors", "total_budget": 1000000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 10000, "employed_q2": 78, "credentialed": 50, "cost_per_employed_q2": 12820.51282051282, "cost_per_credential": 20000, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 78, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 50, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "below" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": 20821.69230769231, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": 50, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "below" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": 50, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "below" } ], "indicators_scored": 5, "indicators_met": 2, "indicators_exceeded": 2, "annualized_earnings": 83286.76923076923, "sector_baseline_annual": 69056, "earnings_gain_annual": 14230.769230769234, "annual_tax_recapture": 333000.0000000001, "breakeven_months": 36.03603603603602, "three_year_net_benefit": -999.9999999996508, "return_per_dollar_3yr": 0.9990000000000003, "grade": "Below Target", "grade_sub": "Program may benefit from a strategic review", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "056d4ec0467641c3f7fe1a183200e768ceb635104744f39639ad364c91d1736e" }, { "name": "BND-BREAKEVEN-36", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "total_budget": 1000000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "emp_rate_q2": 78, "emp_rate_q4": null, "median_earnings_q2": 20825.25356125356, "credential_rate": null, "skill_gains_rate": null }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Boundary Case", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "other", "sector_label": "Other / Mixed Sectors", "total_budget": 1000000, "participants_enrolled": 100, "participants_exited": 100, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 10000, "employed_q2": 78, "credentialed": null, "cost_per_employed_q2": 12820.51282051282, "cost_per_credential": null, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 78, "target": 76, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 74, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": 20825.25356125356, "target": 6200, "isEarnings": true, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 53, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": null, "target": 56, "isEarnings": false, "status": "na" } ], "indicators_scored": 2, "indicators_met": 2, "indicators_exceeded": 2, "annualized_earnings": 83301.01424501424, "sector_baseline_annual": 69056, "earnings_gain_annual": 14245.014245014245, "annual_tax_recapture": 333333.3333333333, "breakeven_months": 36, "three_year_net_benefit": 0, "return_per_dollar_3yr": 1, "grade": "Moderate", "grade_sub": "Positive return; selected benchmarks need improvement", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "apex_defaults" }, "golden_hash": "7d15a0b0aee8fc9d8b7d311a25854b895d56c2568ffb0ce0ebe2edbc73e6d51c" }, { "name": "BND-WIOA-TARGETS-CALLER", "policy_parameters": { "program_name": "Advanced Manufacturing Cohort 3", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "manufacturing", "total_budget": 500000, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "participants_enrolled": 150, "participants_exited": 120, "emp_rate_q2": 76, "emp_rate_q4": 74, "median_earnings_q2": 6200, "credential_rate": 53, "skill_gains_rate": 56, "wioa_targets": { "adult": { "empRateQ2": 50, "empRateQ4": 50, "medianEarningsQ2": 2000, "credentialRate": 30, "skillGainsRate": 30 } } }, "output_payload": { "program_name": "Advanced Manufacturing Cohort 3", "program_type": "adult", "program_year": "PY 2023", "sector": "manufacturing", "sector_label": "Manufacturing", "total_budget": 500000, "participants_enrolled": 150, "participants_exited": 120, "avg_training_weeks": 16, "cost_per_participant": 3333.3333333333335, "employed_q2": 91, "credentialed": 64, "cost_per_employed_q2": 5494.505494505494, "cost_per_credential": 7812.5, "benchmarks": [ { "key": "emp_rate_q2", "label": "Employment Rate – Q2 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 76, "target": 50, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "emp_rate_q4", "label": "Employment Rate – Q4 After Exit (%)", "userVal": 74, "target": 50, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "median_earnings_q2", "label": "Median Earnings – Q2 ($)", "userVal": 6200, "target": 2000, "isEarnings": true, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "credential_rate", "label": "Credential Attainment (%)", "userVal": 53, "target": 30, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" }, { "key": "skill_gains_rate", "label": "Measurable Skill Gains (%)", "userVal": 56, "target": 30, "isEarnings": false, "status": "exceeds" } ], "indicators_scored": 5, "indicators_met": 5, "indicators_exceeded": 5, "annualized_earnings": 24800, "sector_baseline_annual": 77844, "earnings_gain_annual": -53044, "annual_tax_recapture": 0, "breakeven_months": null, "three_year_net_benefit": -500000, "return_per_dollar_3yr": 0, "grade": "Below Target", "grade_sub": "Program may benefit from a strategic review", "refusal_reason": null, "domain_errors": [], "scope_note": "WIOA performance targets and BLS QCEW sector baselines are inputs to this tool; the sector baselines here are the official QCEW Q3 2023 private-sector weekly wage x52, and the WIOA targets are illustrative defaults carried from the Apex page; WIOA levels are negotiated per State (20 CFR 677.190) — supply your State’s negotiated levels via policy_parameters.wioa_targets. Tax recapture is a fixed 30% effective-rate assumption, not a statutory rate. No PII; a pure function of the declared program inputs.", "targets_source": "caller" }, "golden_hash": "1e4d71ded3061f0f337ddb213d27a579acdbd62b4550b106a60a14e215c3b921" } ] }